- The front cover features the show logo and Tom Peters & The Mayor standing in the middle. In the background throughout the entire cover is a collage of items seen in many of the episodes, such as Calcucorn, Paul Bunyon, ROTY shirt, Barrel Goats, electric guitars, and food.
- On the back cover, the collage of items continues. At the top there is a bulletin board with some memorabilia from the show, such as the Jefferton wrestling team's bumper sticker, Mayor's parchment poetry, and some of Tom's postcards.
- Inside, the DVD listings are designed to look like a menu from Fishanelli's restaurant. The DVD discs have graphics of food on them.
- Commentary track on every episode
- That's Amazing!: How Do They Make That Show?
- The Night of 1000 Stars: Celebrity Sessions
- A Look Behind
- Original Toms
- Whoops?: Deleted Scenes
- Tiny Tune Town: Music From the Show
- Here's the Scoop: Married News Outtakes
- Bob Zone: A Tribute to Bob Odenkirk
- Boiling Point: Behind the Scenes Season Two
- Adult Swim and TGTTM Promos
- An Artist's Touch: Artwork from the Show